“The people who think I’m wacky or who are skeptics — doesn’t phase me. I’m not here to convince you of the afterlife. I’m here for the spirits. I want to tell their story.” -Mariah Kunau, paranormal investigator (Season 2, Episode 5 of the Netflix 6-part series Surviving Death)

I had to find out for myself

In the episode, she and Christopher Davalos (at the time the Director of Visitor Services to the Morris-Jumel Mansion in Manhattan’s Washington Heights neighborhood) commune with the ghost of Aaron Burr, third vice president of the United States who was married in the mansion in 1833. Real or staged — who knows? My curiosity was piqued.

I first visited the mansion — now a museum — in late October 2022. Inspired by the Netflix episode. I wanted to find out for myself: is this place legitimately haunted?

My first visit there was a self-guided tour, and on that particular day there was a Día de Los Muertos interactive exhibit in the mansion’s basement, where visitors could make an artistic offering to a deceased loved one.

A welcome touch, and it reminded me that communing with the dead can be whimsical and doesn’t necessarily have to be spooky.
My ofrenda (offering)
The Morris-Jumel mansion (65 Jumel Terrace, New York, NY 10032) was built in 1765 and is Manhattan’s oldest surviving house. The City of New York acquired it in the early 1900s and it now operates as a museum.
This pair of stray cats on the premises felt like an auspicious sign: one white, one black. If I could name them, I’d call them Yin and Yang.

Now for my little tour . . .

The main hallway, just beyond the front door
This oil portrait on canvas (by Alcide Ercole, 1854) graces the wall in the entryway. Featured are three of the mansion’s former tenants, Eliza Jumel and her descendants.
A portion of one of the bedrooms on the second floor. In the background is a portrait of the mansion itself.
The Octagon Room on the first floor is much more ornately decorated than it was during filming of Surviving Death
The Octagon Room again — stunning!

During that first visit, I did hear some unexplained knocks while I was (to my knowledge) the only museum guest in the basement. I left that day thinking “Maybe!”

Flash forward to 2026, when I learned of the paranormal tour taking place at the mansion on several autumn weekend evenings. What made the tour sound especially appealing to me was that the mansion was under construction and therefore closed off to the general public. Also, the tour was limited to a dozen people per evening, which would (I hope) allow me to get up close and personal with the museum and any — ahem — inhabitants.

I arrived in the neighborhood rather early that night, and the gates were still closed. I circled the premises a few times, hoping to pass the time. I was on the phone with a loved one, as well, and the call kept dropping. Paranormal activity or just poor cell service? I will never know for sure.

The tour convened in the basement, where I had made my ofrenda during the exhibit four years prior. Each of the visitors on the tour was given an overview of the building’s history, including information about alleged paranormal activity in the building. We were also introduced to various methods of detecting otherworldly activity, such as through EMF meters (pictured below), dowsing rods, and electronic voice phenomenon (EVP) as ways to “commune.”

EMF reader and card with info about one of the mansion’s former occupants
The mansion was all lit up in colorful, warm lights and battery-powered tealight candles on the night of the tour.
Second floor
Another photo taken on the second floor

In small groups, we were allowed to enter various rooms of the mansion. We learned about the history and significance of each room as we entered: who might have occupied it and whether they would be willing to communicate with us via the aforementioned paranormal equipment. It was fun to try out the dowsing rods (“Cross for no, open for yes,” IYKYK) and to see the EVF meters light up around certain supposed hot spots.

Overall, I enjoyed the tour and would absolutely go back again. The mansion is architecturally and historically significant, not to mention charming. Whether or not it has ethereal occupants is anyone’s guess. And as much as my critical thinking skills tell me: “There is not enough evidence,” another part of me wants to believe. Not to mention, I did come away with one photo from that night that is pretty spooky, in the basement of the mansion. I haven’t altered this photo at all — besides brightening the color using the iPhone “vivid” filter. If you loom closely, on the rear wall you might notice what looks to be the silhouette of a woman’s face. Is it the imprint of Eliza Jumel, or someone else who left their etheric imprint on the building? Or maybe just the product of an overactive imagination. I’ll let you decide.

Do you see what I see?

Your comments are most welcome.